...

Initiate I-9 Reverify option is available to I-9 Specialists if the process associated with the I-9 ID chosen is in completed status and if the documents entered in I-9 Section 2 are going to expire in the next 90 days or already expired. 

Note: It is very important to note that this process can be Initiated only if all the processes associated with the I-9 are all in Process Completed status.

Who can initiate I-9 Reverify process through I-9 Console?

...